36th District Candidates’ Forum: Lots of “Me, too” and a Surprise

August 19, 2010

CENTREVILLE– Candidates for the 36th District state House of Delegates and Senate seats squared off Tuesday night in a non-partisan issues forum here, with most Republican candidates saying the same things, in the same words, while Democrats had a mixed presentation that even elicited that rare commodity at a candidates’ forum: laughter.

  The forum, sponsored jointly by the Kent and Queen Anne’s counties chapters of the non-partisan League of Women Voters, drew a small crowd of about 45 people. The format of the event placed Democrats  and Republicans in separate panels so there was no back-and-forth between potential general election rivals. In the few contested primary races, rivals were allowed to respond to each others answers. But the format, which drew all questions from people in the audience who could direct which candidate should address it, left out some candidates who were not allowed to address a question if it was not aimed at them. At times, candidates not allowed to answer a question seemed to be chafing at the bit to respond, too.

  That problem was most evident in the Democratic panel discussion.  William Manlove, of Cecil County, who is unopposed in the primary and will face incumbent Republican Del. Michael Smigiel in November, was frequently excluded from answering questions posed to the two Democrats running in the party primary for the chance to challenge incumbent Republican  Sen. E.J. Pipkin in the general election. Robert Alt, the former mayor of Elkton, is running against Steven Mumford, a political newcomer from Chestertown, in the primary for Senate.

(Missing from the panel was Arthur Hock, a Democrat who is running for the Kent County seat formerly held by Mary Roe Walkup, who is retiring.)

  Mumford, who has an eclectic background as a professional dancer and operates a historic homes tour business, drew laughter several times for his comments and demonstrated a mostly solid understanding of Kent and Queen Anne’s county issues. (He didn’t address specific issues regarding Cecil County, which he visited recently to appear at a firemen’s parade, waving a colonial tri-cornered hat.)  Perhaps because expectations were low, his performance at the forum was a surprise.

  On the state budget crisis, Mumford quipped, “Maybe Sen. Pipkin can help us out– he’s a multi-millionaire”  and on whether an additional Bay Bridge crossing is needed to ease traffic congestion, he joked that as a swimming instructor he would provide lessons to anyone willing to make the crossing by water, before discussing the issues seriously.

   Mumford was knowledgable on a key local issue: the “FASTC” project that would have brought a federal State Department security training center to a large Queen Anne’s County farm. The project was initially welcomed by local officials but they backpedaled after pressure brought by local anti-growth groups and the federal government withdrew the proposal.   Mumford said that while the 400 or so jobs the facility would have brought to Queen Anne’s were “lost” to that county, the project might still be salvaged and located in Kent or Caroline counties in the 36th District. He said he had talked with local economic development officials who were working with some local farmers interested in offering their property for the facility. “It’s not a dead issue yet,” he said.

  Alt, his primary opponent, admitted he was not up to speed on the issue and said, “I don’t know much about this issue but I’ll try to learn more.” (In comments posted on our short Tuesday night bulletin on the forum, Alt said he has researched the issue further and said it was a tough issue to address at the state level and was best decided by the county government.)

  Manlove said he had “mixed emotions” about weighing the “property rights” of the farmer to sell his land and the jobs the project would create against his concerns that a large farm would be taken out of production, when he has fought for years to preserve agriculture.

  Several questions posed to the Democrats focused on environmental issues, with Manlove outlining his efforts while President of the Cecil County Commissioners to promote “smart growth” policies to limit development in rural areas, keep farms in business and improve water quality through modernization of sewage systems. At one point, the former dairy farmer took exception to a suggestion that farmers were at fault for water pollution: “I resent blaming farmers for all the runoff,” Manlove said, listing other causes such as pavement run-off and failing sewage and septic systems.

  Alt cited his experience working to upgrade municipal wastewater treatment systems. He said a key issue for the state to address is the growing problem of  “saltwater infiltration into drinking water wells” in rural areas on the Shore.

  Alt also offered a suggestion for easing the chronic traffic congestion on Kent Island and Route 50: eliminate the eastbound tolls during peak travel times to end bottlenecks caused by backups at the toll plaza.

   On job creation, Alt said he had “knocked on doors” to bring business to Elkton and would do the same as a state Senator, working with town and county governments in a coordinated effort.  He emphasized his campaign platform to improve communication between local government and the state delegation. (Smigiel and Pipkin have had particularly strained relations with the Cecil County government in recent years.) Mumford, citing his membership in the Screen Actors Guild, said the state should promote the film industry and improve tax breaks to movie companies to shoot films here. Manlove was not allowed to answer the question.

   During the Republican portion of the forum, incumbents Smigiel and Pipkin were joined by incumbent Del. Richard Sossi, who represents Queen Anne’s County. Sossi is being opposed in the Republican primary by Stephen S. Hershey, Jr., who also attended the event. (No Democrats have filed for the Queen Anne’s County seat.) Pipkin is facing a GOP primary challenge from Donald Alcorn, but he did not attend the forum. Also present was Jay Jacobs, the mayor of Rock Hall who is running for the Walkup seat against Democrat Hock.

   The Republicans took pretty much the same position on the issues, often using the same words. On FASTC, most said it was a matter  of “property rights” and something to be decided by county government, with the state delegation having no role to play. But Hershey added that FASTC, and another Wye Mills project opposed by environmentalists, showed “The delegation does need to step in and push these types of projects. ”

    Pipkin offered a spirited defense of his environmental record when a questioner asked about his poor ratings on scorecards of the Maryland League of Conservation voters, which has given him marks of zero to below 40 percent in recent years. He cited his work as a private citizen to stop dumping of dredge spoil material in the Bay off Kent  Island and his work in the recent legislative session to bar dumping of rubble fill. He said he was penalized on the scorecard because he opposed a solar energy bill that “sounds nice” but in fact was “crony capitalism” that would have cost consumers millions.

   The most varied responses came to a broad question: what issue is your top priority to benefit the 36th District.

   Smigiel declared that it was to change the state Constitution. He said he wanted to allow local referendum voting on any local tax increase, and to clarify that local government condemnation of property through eminent domain could only be for public uses, like a school. (Smigiel and Pipkin have been at war this year with the Cecil County Commissioners and tried but failed to pass legislation in Annapolis to mandate what property tax levels the county could set.)

   Jacobs took a more down-to-earth approach: stem the “exodus” of small business from the Shore through lower taxes and incentives to encourage entrepeneurship in the area. Pipkin said his priority was to rein in government spending and cut property taxes and he also urged action to lower utility bills. Hershey declared that the “liberal majority in Annapolis” must be stopped and the corporate income tax should be cut.

    Sossi took a broader approach, saying “We dont have the luxury of picking just one issue” to focus on. He said job creation was crucial, through small business incentives and he said he would support a rollback of the one percentage point increase in the state sales tax enacted under Gov. Martin O’Malley’s administration.

    Sossi was the only candidate to address issues pertaining to seniors, who represent a growing proportion of Shore residents. He said “affordable housing” has become a serious problem in the district because seniors can’t afford to keep up their homes. He said he favors a change in state income tax law to allow a tax credit to offset income from pensions,  such as some other states provide.


Bill Manlove Files Against Smigiel for Delegate

April 7, 2010

    It will be a battle between a man of few words and a man whose words never end when former Cecil County Commissioners Board President William (Bill) Manlove, of Earleville, files as a Democrat to run against incumbent Republican Michael Smigiel for the 36th District Delegate seat. Manlove will file his candidate and campaign finance committee papers in Annapolis on Friday, April 9.

   Manlove is scheduled to meet with influential state Democratic leaders, including House Speaker Michael Busch, in Annapolis. Speaker Busch is no fan of Smigiel and even contemplated throwing Smigiel, who is an attorney, off the House Judiciary Committee in 2009. (That gambit failed when another delegate, a Baltimore City Democrat, was also targeted for ouster but the powerful city Democrats protested, with the result that both committee members were allowed to keep their seats.)  Busch has a Democratic House slate fundraising organization that could help Manlove, who in the past has run low-budget local campaigns but will need to step up the fundraising to challenge Smigiel.

   The 36th District covers part of Cecil County, all of Kent and Queen Anne’s counties, plus part of Caroline County. Residents of those counties vote for a total of three delegates, one from each of the three larger counties. So candidates have to appeal to voters outside their own home county.

   Manlove, who grew up and worked on his family’s dairy farm in Earleville for many years, has enjoyed strong political support in the southern end of Cecil County that he represented as a Commissioner. He stands to benefit from strong name recognition and contacts honed over many years in his base area, which is the northernmost section of the 36th House district.

   Smigiel, of Chesapeake City, is particularly vulnerable in his home county. In his last re-election bid in 2006, he lost Cecil County to Democrat Mark Guns by more than 600 votes. But Smigiel won his last race with a strong showing in Queen Anne’s County, no doubt helped by the then-residency in Queen Anne’s of his Republican political ally, Sen. E.J. Pipkin. But Pipkin now resides in Elkton and it is unclear how much influence his alliance with Smigiel will hold in Queen Anne’s.

   As a former farmer, Manlove is well known in the influential, but dwindling, agricultural community in the 36th District. Manlove also has strong ties to the burgeoning land preservation and environmental groups, stemming from his opposition to development in rural areas and his support of Transfer of Development Rights legislation to preserve farmland while a county Commissioner. Those credentials should serve him well in Queen Anne’s County, where a past county Board of Commissioners was thrown out of office a few years ago and replaced by slow-to-no growth politicians.

   Smigiel received a zero positive rating last year from the influential Maryland League of Conservation Voters. He responded by launching a blistering attack on the group and challenging its policies and priorities.

  Manlove has always been a low key leader, in contrast to the high volatility quotient of Smigiel. In his announcement, Manlove emphasizes his determination to avoid a “waste [of] time and energy on confrontation and political bickering.”  He promised to “roll up my sleeves and work with the counties in the district to make sure their residents’ voices are heard in Annapolis” and to “work to solve problems before they become a crisis.”

    Smigiel and Pipkin have a long track record of seeking to micro-manage the Cecil County Board of Comissioners, which escalated this year with their advocacy of state legislation to mandate the local property tax rate and to set a referendum on binding arbitration and collective bargaining for Sheriff’s Deputies. The tax rate proposal was killed in committee and the Deputies’ bill was watered down in the Senate to reflect most of what the county comissioners had already supported: collective bargaining with non-binding mediation, with no referendum on the matter.

   This year’s battles between Smigiel/Pipkin and the Cecil County Commissioners– a majority of whom are their fellow Republicans– have left a bitter taste among many Cecil residents, including Republicans. Although they won’t say it in public, many Republicans in the county have privately encouraged Manlove to run for Delegate.

  And the recent battles played a role in convincing Manlove to run for Delegate, according to informed sources. 

   One significant factor in the contest may be the role of the “Tea Party” movement that has been mostly aligned with Republicans and the “Young Republicans” in Cecil County that have been aligned with Smigiel. They represent an Internet-savvy new force in local politics. Some of the most ardent “Tea Party” and “Liberty” partisans in the District are based in Queen Anne’s County.  In addition, Smigiel has enlisted a former aide to Pipkin, Andi Morony, as his chief of staff and she has strong ties to mainstream Queen Anne’s County Republicans.

    But many Republican activists in the District will be focused on the Congressional race between incumbent Democrat Frank Kratovil and the expected Republican nominee, Andy Harris.  And the “Young Republicans” are fielding candidates for Cecil County Commissioner in three local races, meaning their attention will be diverted to more local contests.